Thread:Topaz123/@comment-30384903-20160311194150/@comment-30384903-20160312202622

Topaz123 wrote: If there is no name given shouldn't we just go ahead with what the movie said.

No, like what I've been trying to point out, if it the situation is "there is no name given  in the books ", then "no name given" should be seen as the canon information, for the book series is what the majority of the fans considered as canon.

Personally I have nothing against the film adaptation, I watched it, thought it was mediocre, but definitely didn't think it was the worst thing in the world; however, basing purely on statistics and numbers, clearly most people were disappointed in the film so much that there were no sequels due to the poor box office performance.

Sorry, getting a bit off track. I read the 4th book and the 2 books from the spin-offs, and I only remember her as "Mrs. Lincon", then again, I don't have the best memory so I could be wrong, but imagine if it really was like the scenario where she actually wasn't named in the books, hardcore fans of the series wouldn't recognized the page title, cuz in their minds "Mrs. Lincon" was always simply "Mrs. Lincon".

Anyways, thanks for answering! Since this is an issue neither of us can provide a clear answer unless we go through all the books, I will start a community discussion later and see if anyone can help out.